CONNECTICUT
This document may be freely copied, printed, or distributed
for personal, nonprofit, governmental, or educational use, if the copy displays
this permission statement with the copyright: © Pinion Feather Press, LLC, 2020,
2023.
WHO: Anyone MAY report reasonably
suspected child abuse or neglect, as may mandated reporters acting outside of their
professional capacity. [Gen. Stat. § 17a-103]
These are mandatory (MUST report or
cause a report to be made): • Physicians,
surgeons, residents, interns, nurses, medical examiners, dentists, dental
hygienists, optometrists, chiropractors, podiatrists, physician assistants,
pharmacists, or physical therapists • Psychologists or other mental health
professionals • School employees: Teachers, substitute teachers, school
administrators, school superintendents, guidance counselors, psychologists,
social workers, nurses, physicians, school paraprofessionals, or coaches
employed by a local or regional board of education or a private elementary, middle,
or high school or any other person who, in performing duties, has regular
contact with students • Social workers • Police officers, juvenile
or adult probation officers, or parole officers • Clergy members • Alcohol and
drug counselors, marital & family therapists, professional counselors,
sexual assault counselors, or domestic violence counselors • Licensed foster
parents • Licensed behavior analysts • Emergency medical services providers •
Any person paid to care for a child in any public or private facility, child
daycare center, group daycare home, or family daycare home that is licensed by
the State • Employees of the Department of Children & Families (DCF), the
Department of Public Health, and the Office of Early Childhood who are
responsible for licensing child daycare centers, group daycare homes, family
daycare homes, or youth camps • The Child Advocate and any employee of his/her
Office • Family relations counselor trainees or family services supervisors
employed by the Judicial Department. [Gen.
Stat. §§ 17a-101; 53a-65]
·
NOTE: The mandate is limited to observations
made in the ordinary course of work.
·
STANDARD: [Gen. Stat. § 17a-101a; -103; 46b-120] Child means under age 18 and not
legally emancipated.
(1)
For most mandatory reporters: in the
ordinary course of work, has reasonable cause to know or suspect that a child has:
(a) been abused or neglected; or (b) a nonaccidental physical injury that is at
variance with the account given; or (c) been placed at imminent risk of serious
harm.
o BELIEF: A mandated
reporter’s suspicion or belief may rely on: observations; allegations; facts;
or statements by a child, victim, or third party. It does NOT require certainty
or probable cause.
(2)
For any school employee: in the ordinary
course of work, the same standard as for other mandatory reporters but further
includes: reasonable cause to suspect or believe that (d) any student in a
technical high school or local or regional board of education (except in adult
education), has been abused by a school employee.
(3)
For other reporters (including mandatory
reporters outside of their mandates): reasonable
cause to suspect or believe that any child is in danger of being abused, or has
been abused or neglected.
·
PRIVILEGE: (1) Privilege is suspended for confidentiality
with psychologists, physicians, marital and family therapists, social workers,
professional counselors, and educational professions. (2) The laws are in
conflict here for clergy-penitent privilege, and for counselor-counselee
privilege for battered women and sexual assault. [https://www.cga.ct.gov/2002/rpt/2002-R-0528.htm] (3) Lawyers are not mandated
categorically and attorney-client privilege appears intact.
WHEN: For mandated reporters: oral report within 12 HOURS; follow-up
written report within 48 HOURS after that.
[Gen. Stat. §§ 17a-101a; 17a-101b; 17a-101c; 17a-101h]
WHERE & HOW:
[Gen. Stat. §§
17a-101a; 17a-101b; 17a-101c; 17a-101h]
·
Usually for mandated
reporters: (1) initial oral report by phone or in person, to (a)
the hotline, (b) Department of Children and Families (DCF), OR (c) a law
enforcement agency; and (2) follow up with a written report
to DCF. [Gen.
Stat. § 17a-101b]
·
Mandated reporters on staff of a public or
private institution or facility that provides care for the child
OR public or private school: have the same protocol but must also
submit a COPY of the written report, to whomever is in charge of that
organization.
·
Reporters with no mandate
or acting outside their mandate: may make an oral OR written
report to any of (a) the hotline (oral), (b) DCF, or (c) a law enforcement
agency.
·
SUSPICIOUS DEATH: Reporting is to local
law enforcement. [Gen. Stat. § 17a-101b]
· In the event of imminent danger: Dial 911; report
afterward
Connecticut does
not officially advise this but others do and it is ordinary practice there.
· Connecticut DCF’s CareLine: 1 (800) 842-2288 [TDD phones, 1 (800) 624-5518]
For more info: https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Reporting-Child-Abuse-and-Neglect
The CareLine
operates 24/7. All calls are recorded.
·
Connecticut DCF directory: see: https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Contact-Us
·
Connecticut law enforcement directory: see: https://www.usacops.com/ct/
· Form DCF-136 for written reports
(downloadable, fillable PDF) is sent to the relevant area office; the form
lists 15 offices with street address, phone, TDD, and fax info: see
https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/DCF/Policy/NEW-fillin-Forms/dcf-136-Fillin-O.pdf?la=en
·
REPORT DETAILS: Mandated oral and
written reports must provide, if known: (a) names and addresses of the child
and his/her parents or others responsible for care; (b) child’s age and gender;
(c) nature and extent of injuries, maltreatment, or neglect; (d) approximate
date and time of the harms; (e) any info on previous harms to the child or
siblings; (f) how the reporter learned of the situation; (g) suspected abuser’s
name; (h) reasons for suspecting him/her; (i) info on prior cases in which s/he
was suspected of harming a child; and (j) any action taken to assist the child
(treatment, shelter, etc.). [Gen. Stat. § 17a-101d] Form DCF-136 also asks: (k) the child’s
race; (l) parents or other persons responsible phone number; (m) suspected
perpetrator’s address and phone number, if known; (n) suspected perpetrator’s
relationship to the child; (o) names and ages of the child’s siblings, if
known; (p) reporter’s name, agency, phone, agency address, city, position, and
race.
·
REPORTER PROTECTION: (1) Reporters may withhold their names,
but DCF uses best efforts to obtain them and their addresses. [Gen. Stat. §§ 17a-101d; 17a-103] (2) The reporter names are confidential by request
or if DCF determines that disclosure may be detrimental to reporter safety or
interests; but statutory exceptions exist for DCF, investigators, prosecutors, courts,
licensing, and academic administrators. [Gen.
Stat. § 17a-28(f)] (3) Reporters in
good faith are immune from civil and criminal liability unless the reporter
perpetrated or caused the abuse or neglect; also, medical malpractice is not
immunized. [Gen. Stat. § 17a-101e(b)]
WHY: (1) Failure to make a mandated report or
be timely for it is a class A misdemeanor; but is class E if it
is: (1a) a repeat offense; (1b) willful, intentional, or grossly negligent; or
(1c) the person knew of the abuse or neglect. (2) Intentional,
unreasonable interference with mandated reports, or attempts or conspiracy to
do so, is a class D felony, but minors and other students (technical and
regional non-adult-education) are exempt from this rule. Violators of (1) and
(2) must participate in an educational or training program. (3) Employer
retaliation for a report is punishable by civil penalties < $2,500 and other
equitable relief. [As to (1)-(3)
above: Gen. Stat. §§ 17a-101a; -101e(a)] (4) Knowingly false reports are
punishable by < 1 year imprisonment and/or a fine of < $2,000. [Gen. Stat. § 17a-101e(c)-(d)]
WHAT: Connecticut defines when children are neglected
(abandonment, non-provision, or injurious conditions), abused
(non-accidental or implausible physical injuries; malnutrition, sexual
abuse/exploitation, deprivation, emotional abuse, or cruel punishment) or uncared
for (homelessness, inability to provide specialized care, or
trafficking). [Gen. Stat. § 46b-120]
Initial Screening Criteria (DCF): Urgency: (a) For
a child who is at imminent risk of physical harm or has another emergency, staff act within 2 hours. (b) If the alleged
perpetrator is someone responsible for the child’s health, welfare, or care OR has access to the child OR
entrusted with the child’s care, staff act immediately (< 72 hours). (c) For
all other reports, staff act within 72 hours. [Gen. Stat. §
17a-101g] BUT: (d) For any oral report
alleging sexual abuse or serious physical abuse or serious
neglect, DCF must report to the appropriate state or local law
enforcement agency within 12 hours. [https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Reporting-Child-Abuse-and-Neglect]
Reportable: The statutes list perpetrator types indirectly.
[Gen. Stat. §
46b-120(4),(5),(6)] DCF identifies responsible persons as (i) the
person responsible for the child’s health, welfare or care; (ii) person given
access; or (iii) person entrusted with the child’s care. [https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Child-Abuse-and-Neglect-Definitions]
(1) Implicitly anyone who is responsible for – or controls – the child’s
welfare is reportable if suspected of: (a) any NEGLECT (abandonment,
non-provision, or injurious conditions) during their watch; (b) any ABUSE that
includes malnutrition or deprivation of necessities, or cruel punishment; or
(c) being unable to provide [needed] specialized care for their UNCARED-FOR
child.
(2)
Implicitly anyone is
reportable for: (a) ABUSE (physical, sexual abuse / exploitation, or emotional
abuse); or (b) an UNCARED-FOR child being homeless or trafficked.
Neglect is by a person responsible for the child's health, welfare or care, or
who has access to the child or is entrusted with his/her care. It involves any
of: (a) abandonment; (b) denial of proper physical, educational, emotional, or
moral care and attention; or (c) permitting a child to live in injurious conditions.
It may occur by action or inaction. [Gen. Stat. § 46b-120(4); https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Child-Abuse-and-Neglect-Definitions]
(A)
Abandonment means a parent's failure to maintain a reasonable degree of interest, concern
or responsibility as to the welfare of the child. “Maintain” means continuing,
not merely sporadic. [In re Sydnei
V., 168 Conn. App. 538, 548, 147 A.3d 147 (2016)]
(B)
Physical neglect: EXAMPLES: (a) inadequate food; (b) malnutrition; (c) inadequate clothing;
(d) inadequate housing or shelter; (d) erratic, deviant, or impaired care; (e) action/inaction
resulting in death; (f) abandonment; (f) action/inaction resulting in failure
to thrive; (g) transience; (h) inadequate supervision (child alone or not well
monitored for an excessive duration at his/her age and stage of development);
and (i) holding the child responsible for care of siblings beyond his/her
ability.
(C)
Medical neglect is failure, refusal, or needless delay in getting necessary
medical, dental or mental health care. EXAMPLES are: (a) frequently missed
appointments; and (b) lack of diligence for life-threatening, acute or chronic
conditions.
(D)
Educational
neglect means that a parent or other person with
control of a child age 5 or older and under age 18 who is not a high school
graduate: (a) fails to enroll the child; (b) fails to allow the child to attend
school or receive home instruction required by law; and/or (c) fails to ensure the
child attends school regularly if enrolled.
(1)
EXCEPTION: Treatment by an accredited
Christian Science practitioner in lieu of medical care, is NOT medical neglect. [Gen. Stat. § 46b-120(6)]
(E)
Emotional neglect is denial of proper care and attention, or failure to respond, where it
affects a child negatively or seriously interferes with his/her emotional
development. EXAMPLES include expectations that are inappropriate for the
child's developmental level; and lack of supportiveness, attentiveness, and
affection. INDICATORS in the child are the same as for emotional
maltreatment below: (a) depression; (b) withdrawal; (c) low self-esteem;
(d) anxiety; (e) fear; (f) aggression or passivity; (g) emotional instability;
(h) sleep disturbances; (i) health complaints with no medical basis; (j) behavior inappropriate for the age or stage
of development; (k) suicidal thoughts; (l) extreme dependence; (m) academic
regression; and/or (n) trust issues.
(F)
Moral neglect means exposing, allowing, or encouraging the
child to engage in illegal or reprehensible activities by the person
responsible for the child’s health, welfare or care or person given access or
person entrusted with the child’s care. EXAMPLES of activities to avoid
include: (a) stealing; (b) using drugs and/or alcohol; and (c) involving a child
in committing a crime, directly or by caregiver indifference.
(G)
Permitting a child to live in injurious
conditions. EXAMPLES include: (a) caregiver substance
abuse [because it affects the caregiver’s example, mood or ability]; (b)
prenatal substance abuse; (b) caregiver psychiatric problems; (c) witnessing
family violence; (d) witnessing other violence that might affect a child’s
safety; (e) non-accidental, negligent
exposure to drug trafficking and/or substance abuse; (f) voluntarily, knowingly
using disqualified caregivers, e.g., sex offenders and persons subject to
restraining orders; (g) non-accidental or negligent exposure to porn or sexual
acts; (h) inability to provide adequate childcare consistently; or (i)
inability to provide a safe environment.
Abuse inflicts any of (1) physical or nonaccidental injuries; (2) injuries
inconsistent with the history (account) given of them; and or (3) maltreatment
resulting in (a) malnutrition, (b) sexual
molestation or exploitation; (c) deprivation of necessities, (d) emotional
maltreatment, or (e) cruel punishment. [Gen. Stat. § 46b-120(5);
https://portal.ct.gov/DCF/1-DCF/Child-Abuse-and-Neglect-Definitions]
(A)
Physical abuse includes: (a) excessive physical punishment; (b) bruises, scratches,
lacerations; (c) burns and/or scalds by fire, chemicals, cigarettes, matches,
electricity, scalding water, friction, etc.; (d) bone fractures, dislocations,
sprains, strains, displacements, hematomas, etc.; (e) head injuries; (f) internal
injuries; (g) death; (h) misuse of medical treatments or therapies.
(1)
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE: Connecticut forbids
exposure of a child under age 16 to domestic violence against others in the
home, if it risks physical or moral harm to the child. [Gen. Stat. § 53-21]
(B)
Malnutrition means medically diagnosed malnutrition by an established caregiver;
(C)
Sexual abuse / exploitation non-accidentally exposes the child to
sexual conduct.
(1)
SEXUAL ABUSE
includes any of: (a) rape; (b) penetration by a finger,
penis or foreign object; (c) oral / genital contact; (d) indecent exposure for
the offender’s sexual gratification, or to shame, humiliate, shock, or control
the victim; (e) incest; (f) fondling, including kissing, for the same reasons;
(g) a sexually transmitted disease or condition; and (h) other verbal, written
or physical behavior that is not overtly sexual but designed to “groom” a child
for future sexual abuse.
(2)
SEXUAL EXPLOITATION of a child
includes: (a) to possess, manufacture, or distribute child porn; (b) online
enticement for sexual acts; (c) child prostitution; (d) child-sex tourism; (e)
sending unsolicited obscene material; (f) a misleading domain name likely to
attract a child to an inappropriate website; and (g) coerced or forced
participation in, or negligent exposure to, porn and/or sexual behavior.
(3)
CONTEXT: INCEST is marriage or
(impliedly opposite-sex) intercourse with one’s: parent or stepparent,
grandparent, child or stepchild, grandchild, sibling, aunt or uncle, or niece
or nephew. [Gen. Stat. §§
53a-72a(a)(2),(b); 46b-21]
(4)
CONTEXT: THE AGE OF CONSENT is 16. (a)
Children age 13, 14, or 15 may consent to a person no more than 3 years older.
(b) There is NO consent if the child has a mental disability or disease is
physically helpless. (c) The age of consent is 18 to a guardian or others responsible
for the child’s welfare. (d) There is NO consent to someone with supervisory or
disciplinary authority over the child in a hospital or other institution or to
a psychotherapist in sessions, or by a patient or former patient if emotionally
dependent, or by therapeutic deception. (f) There is NO consent to sex by
deceptive health care. (g) There is NO consent to: (i) an employee of the
child’s school; (ii) the child’s coach; (iii) a professional age 20 or more in
a position of power, authority or supervision over the child; or (iv) someone
with supervisory or disciplinary authority over child for the Commissioner of
Developmental Services [Gen. Stat. § 53a-71]
(D)
Deprivation of necessities means to the point of harm to the child.
(E)
Emotional maltreatment includes rejecting, degrading, brutal or intimidating acts or
statements, and isolating and/or victimizing a child by cruel, unusual, or
excessive disciplinary methods. Indicators may include: (a) depression; (b)
withdrawal; (c) low self-esteem; (d) anxiety; (e) fear; (f) aggression or
passivity; (g) emotional instability; (h) sleep disturbances; (i) health
complaints with no medical basis; (j) behavior inappropriate for the age or
stage of development; (k) suicidal thoughts; (l) extreme dependence; (m)
academic regression; and/or (n) trust issues.
(F)
Cruel punishment is not defined. In other jurisdictions it is often defined to include:
physical brutality; confinement in close quarters; tying or tethering the
child; degrading punishments (e.g., being forced to eat dog food from a dog
bowl); etc.
Uncared-for children include those who are: (a) homeless; or (b) in a
home that cannot provide [needed] specialized care required for the child’s
physical, emotional, or mental condition; and/or (c) trafficking
victims. [Gen. Stat. § 46b-120(6)]
(A)
Trafficking means any act to: (a) recruit, abduct,
transport, harbor, transfer, sell or receive persons (b) within national or
across international borders, by (c) force, coercion, fraud or deception, to
(d) place them into slavery or slavery-like conditions, forced labor or
services, such as forced prostitution or sexual services, domestic servitude,
bonded sweatshop labor or other debt bondage. [Gen Stat. §46a-170(i)]
This document provides legal information, not legal advice.
F. Russell Denton, Ph.D., Esq.
ISBN No. 979-8-9886484-0-6
©️ Pinion Feather Press, LLC, 2020, 2023.